No. 01 · The signature work

The ruling is wrong. The clock is already running.

A supervisory writ asks a higher court to intervene now — before the harm becomes permanent. It is the signature work of this practice.

Jerome Matthews on the steps of a Louisiana courthouseSupervisory Writs
Jerome Matthews in a law library with St. Louis Cathedral visible through the window The writ desk
What a writ is

Some rulings cannot wait for the end of the case.

Most trial court decisions can only be challenged after final judgment — months or years away. But some rulings do their damage immediately: a suppression motion denied, bail set impossibly high, privileged material ordered produced, a double jeopardy claim brushed aside, a case that should have been quashed rolling forward anyway.

Louisiana law gives the courts of appeal supervisory jurisdiction to review those rulings now. The mechanism is the supervisory writ: notice of intent filed in the trial court, a return date set, and a complete, self-contained application filed in the reviewing court — built so the judges can rule without waiting for anything else.

It is precision work on a short fuse, and it is the work this practice is known for.

The writ window

The return date arrives fast — and it does not wait for anyone to feel ready.

Under Rule 4-3 of the Uniform Rules of the Louisiana Courts of Appeal, the trial court sets the return date — in criminal cases, generally not more than 30 days from the ruling. Extensions exist, but only if requested before the window closes.

How the writ practice works

Four moves, made quickly and in order.

I

Notice of intent.

Filed in the trial court immediately, asking the judge to set the return date. This is the move that protects everything after it.

II

The record.

The order, the transcript, the exhibits, the minute entries — assembled to appellate standards, because the reviewing court sees only what the application gives it.

III

The application.

One disciplined argument, supported and complete, built to be granted. Five loose issues lose to one clean one.

IV

The stay, when needed.

A writ does not automatically stop the proceedings below. Where the harm is imminent, a stay request travels with the application.

Common questions

Asked in nearly every first call.

Does filing a writ stop my trial?

Not by itself. The trial court proceedings continue unless a stay is requested and granted — by the trial court or the reviewing court. Whether to seek a stay is a strategic decision made case by case.

What kinds of rulings can be reviewed by writ?

Interlocutory rulings that cause irreparable harm or present a clear error worth correcting immediately — suppression rulings, bail decisions, discovery orders, recusal issues, double jeopardy claims, and more. The common thread: waiting for an appeal would forfeit the remedy.

How fast do I need to act?

Immediately. The notice of intent must be filed quickly and the return date in criminal matters is generally capped at 30 days from the ruling. Every day spent deciding is a day taken from the application itself.

All frequently asked questions

No case is routine when it is yours

Talk through the case before the next deadline does the talking.

Calls and texts are answered day and night. Share only what you are comfortable sharing — the first conversation is about timing, exposure, and what has to happen next.

504-247-6411